NeGD organizes 'Drone and it's Application' Programme (See 'Corp Brief') Ayush Pavilion: A major attraction at India International Trade Fair 2025 (See 'Corp Brief') CMPDI celebrates 51st CIL & CMPDI Foundation Day (See 'Corp Brief') Whole-of-Society Mobilization to shape India's One Health future: Dr Paul (See 'Corp Brief') JCM will catalyse advanced Low-carbon Technologies: Yadav (See 'Corp Brief') PMLA - Pre-arrest protection would undermine integrity of ongoing investigation, and anticipatory bail in such cases should be granted sparingly: HC (See 'Legal Desk') MyGov's National Space Day Quiz 2025 Winners Experience an Inspiring Journey at ISRO (See 'Corp Brief') NPG assesses 3 Key Projects from Railways and Road (See 'Corp Brief') NHAI launches Raajmarg Infra Investment Managers Pvt. Ltd (See 'Corp Brief') DRDO, DGA, France ink pact to deepen collaboration in defence R&D (See 'Corp Brief') RTI/SEBI - Refusal to disclose certain information justified, where details sought for pertains to commercial interests of third parties & received by SEBI in fiduciary capacity during its regulatory functions & disclosure of which could harm competitive position of relevant entities - YES: SEBI (See 'Legal Desk') TEC, Delhi IIT sign MoU for collaboration on Joint Studies in Telecom Technologies (See 'Corp Brief') MoS urges Indian Diaspora in Baku to Mentor, Invest, and Shape India's Future (See 'Corp Brief') India Responding to Global Textile Demand with Strength and Confidence: MoS (See 'Corp Brief') 60-40 model to be adopted in Sports with 60% Focus on HRD: Scindia (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - When election process was initiated by notifying election and subsequently commenced, writ petition is not maintainable against it without exhausting alternate remedy: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Our goal must be to make natural farming a fully science-backed movement: PM (See 'Corp Brief') AIM, CFA Institute India forge strategic partnership to boost financial literacy (See 'Corp Brief') Indigenous 'CRISPR' based gene therapy launched for Sickle Cell Disease (See 'Corp Brief') PMLA - Question of substitution of attached property by way of any cash deposit or fixed deposit does not arise, if said property directly/indirectly acquired are attached, but not attached as value thereof: SAFEMA (See 'Legal Desk') CCI allows India Resurgence Fund to pick up equity in Digvijay Cement (See 'Corp Brief') CCI okays merger of ADES International Cayman, with and into Shelf Drilling (See 'Corp Brief') IBC - Assignment of loan by lender/bank to new entity does not necessarily require express consent of borrower, but knowledge by borrower would suffice: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Govt introduces new modalities under PMFBY to strengthen farmer protection (See 'Corp Brief') Second regional meeting of Urban Development Ministers held in Hyderabad (See 'Corp Brief') Trade Marks Act - New trade mark be struck off where it seeks to bank on existing goodwill accumulated by original trade mark & where original mark's owner has superior right over trade mark: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Reddy to inaugurate GSI's International Seminar in Jaipur (See 'Corp Brief') Joshi highlights role of technology in strengthening PDS and reaching the poorest (See 'Corp Brief') SAFEMA: If relative or associate of convict/detenue establish that property is not acquired with monies or assets provided by detenu, then properties of relatives/associates cannot be forfeited even if illegally acquired: SAFEMA (See 'Legal Desk') Mandaviya inaugurates EPFO's first-ever Modernised Digital Pavilion at IITF 2025 (See 'Corp Brief') NHAI takes Initiative to Publish Updates for Underbidding Projects on Website (See 'Corp Brief') India, Russia hold High-Level Interagency Consultations in New Delhi (See 'Corp Brief') Gati Shakti Vishwavidyalaya, DRDO sign MoU to develop Smart Tech Solutions (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - Legal heirs who are guilty of misconduct disentitles them to seek indulgence of Court to condone delay: HC (See 'Legal Desk') India unveils ARKA-GKT1, First Generation Energy-Efficient Edge Silicon Chip (See 'Corp Brief') MSME, KVIC, COIR and NSSH Pavilions inaugurated at Trade Fair (See 'Corp Brief') India highlights Rapid Telecom Transformation; Urges Collaborative Cybersecure Future (See 'Corp Brief') 5 institutes of Ministry of Earth Sciences brought under single umbrella (See 'Corp Brief') From Markets to Monuments: Advancing Clean Toilets and Hygienic Spaces (See 'Corp Brief') Capital Market - Fact that transactions in particular contract were reversed with same counterparty for same quantity of units, indicates prior meeting of minds with view to execute reversal trades at pre-determined price: SEBI (See 'Legal Desk') Puri visits Hanwha Ocean's shipbuilding facility in South Korea (See 'Corp Brief') IPR - Mere fact that any mark consists of numbers does not, in itself, make it unregistrable: HC (See 'Legal Desk') IndiaAI Zone unveiled showcasing India's Journey from Action to Impact (See 'Corp Brief') IPR - Counterfeiting not only harms brand reputation but also misleads consumers, making strict legal action necessary to deter such unlawful practices: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Puri holds Shipbuilding Meetings to boost India's Maritime Vision (See 'Corp Brief') Company Law - Company can prosecute any of its officers and when any officer of Company is to be prosecuted, then Section 439 of Companies Act would not be applicable: HC (See 'Legal Desk') AAI showcases future of Aviation at 44th India International Trade Fair 2025 (See 'Corp Brief') IPR - Mere identity or similarity of mark, of which registration is sought, and earlier mark, is not sufficient as ground to reject registration application: HC (See 'Legal Desk') India-Canada Ministerial Dialogue on Trade and Investment concludes (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - Remedy for recovery of money instituted under Article 226 of Constitution of India is not intended to enable claimant to recover monies, recovery of which by suit is barred by limitation: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Government intervention and Corporate governance (See CORP EINSICHT)

Print

SEBI's Current Focus - SECRETARIAL AUDIT

Published: Apr 25, 2025

 By CS Shweta Jain, PCS Partner, Agarwal S. & Associates, New Delhi

 

INTRODUCTION

AUDITING is designed to help us improve by providing genuine feedback from others. Auditing is a tool, technique, and process that is used to guarantee reliability and accuracy of information. Transparency is promoted and compliance with applicable laws and regulations is verified. It ultimately builds trust among stakeholders.

Audits also identify potential errors, irregularities, and fraudulent activities within records. There are many types of audits being conducted in corporates. Some of them are Statutory Audits, Cost Audits, Management Audits, Internal Audits, Secretarial Audits, etc. Today, we are going to gaze into latest amendments in law made pertaining to Secretarial Audit.

Section 204 of the Companies Act, 2013 deals with Secretarial Audit. It provides that every listed company and some other prescribed categories of companies shall annex with its Board's report, a secretarial audit report, given by a company secretary in practice.

Regulation 24A of SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 (LODR) deals with Secretarial Audit. In December 2024, the SEBI amended the Regulation 24A LODR, through the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) (Third Amendment) Regulations, 2024, published in the Gazette on December 13, 2024 followed by a circular dated December 31, 2024, which explained certain aspects of the amendment.

The amended Regulation requires that every listed entity and its material unlisted subsidiaries incorporated in India shall undertake Secretarial Audit by a Secretarial Auditor who shall be a Peer Reviewed Company Secretary and shall annex a Secretarial Audit Report with the annual report of the listed entity.

The aforesaid amendment to Regulation 24A of LODR has caused a lot of uncertainty. Professionals and business organizations are experiencing confusion because of the lack of clarity and the wide range of interpretations of the meaning of amended Regulation 24A. This article will attempt to shed light on some essential aspects of the changes in Regulation 24A of LODR, which may alleviate any doubts or uncertainties.

WHO IS SECRETARIAL AUDITOR

Secretarial Auditor" means a Company Secretary in Practice or a firm of Company Secretary (ies) in practice appointed to conduct the Secretarial Audit.

WHO IS PEER REVIEWED COMPANY SECRETARY

"Peer Reviewed Company Secretary" means a Company Secretary in practice, who is either practicing individually or as a sole proprietor or as a partner of a Peer Reviewed Practice Unit, holding a valid certificate of peer review issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India.

HOW A LISTED COMPANY WOULD APPOINT SECRETARIAL AUDITOR

On the basis of recommendation of board of directors, a listed entity shall appoint or re-appoint:

(i) an individual as Secretarial Auditor for not more than one term of five consecutive years; or

(ii) a Secretarial Audit firm as Secretarial Auditor for not more than two terms of five consecutive years, with the approval of its shareholders in its Annual General Meeting.

HOW a CASUAL VACANCY FOR POST OF SECRETARIAL AUDITOR WOULD BE FILLED UP

The casual vacancy arising out of resignation, death or disqualification of a Secretarial Auditor shall be filled by the board of directors of the listed entity within a period of three months and the secretarial auditor so appointed shall hold office till the conclusion of the next annual general meeting.

WHAT ARE THE SERVICES WHICH CANNOT BE RENDERED BY SECRETARIAL AUDITOR TO CLIENT COMPANY

A Secretarial Auditor appointed under these regulations shall provide to the listed entity only such other services as are approved by the board of directors, but which shall not include any services as specified by the Board in this behalf.

FROM WHICH DATE CHANGES/AMENDMENT INTRODUCED IS EFFECTIVE

With effect from April 1, 2025, every listed entity shall ensure compliance with revised regulations for appointment, re-appointment or continuation of the Secretarial Auditor of the listed entity:

Any association of the individual or the firm as the Secretarial Auditor of the listed entity before March 31, 2025 shall not be considered for the purpose of calculating the tenure.

WHAT IS ELIGIBILITY, QUALIFICATIONS AND DISQUALIFICATIONS CRITERIA OF SECRETARIAL AUDITOR

(a) A person shall be eligible for appointment as a Secretarial Auditor of the listed entity only if such person is a Peer Reviewed Company Secretary and has not incurred any of the disqualifications as specified by the Board.

(b) Where a firm including a limited liability partnership is appointed as Secretarial Auditor of the listed entity, only the partners who are Peer Reviewed Company Secretaries shall be authorised to act and sign on behalf of the firm.

(c) Where a person appointed as Secretarial Auditor of the listed entity incurs any of the disqualifications as specified by the Board, after appointment, such person shall vacate the office as Secretarial Auditor and such vacation shall be deemed to be a casual vacancy in the office of the Secretarial Auditor.

DISQUALIFICATION CRITERIA FOR APPOINTMENT OF SECRETARIAL AUDITORS AS PER SEBI CIRCULAR DATED DECEMBER 31, 2024 -

Following persons shall not be eligible to be appointed / continue as a Secretarial Auditor of the listed entity, namely: -

a) a body corporate other than a limited liability partnership registered under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008;

b) an officer or employee of the listed entity;

c) a person who is a partner, or who is in the employment, of an officer or employee of the listed entity;

d) a person who, or his relative or partner is indebted to the listed entity;

e) a person or a firm who, whether directly or indirectly, has business relationship with the listed entity, or its subsidiary, or its holding or associate entity or subsidiary of such holding entity;

f) a person whose relative is a director or is in the employment of the listed entity as a director or key managerial personnel;

g) a person who is in full time employment elsewhere or a person or a partner of a firm holding appointment as its secretarial auditor, if such persons or partner is at the date of such appointment or reappointment holding appointment as secretarial auditor of 15 or more than 15 companies;

h) a person who has been convicted by a court of an offence involving fraud and a period of ten years has not elapsed from the date of such conviction;

SERVICES NOT TO BE RENDERED BY THE SECRETARIAL AUDITOR AS PER SEBI CIRCULAR DATED DECEMBER 31, 2024 -

A secretarial auditor appointed under the LODR regulations, shall not provide any of the following services:

i. internal audit;

ii. design and implementation of any compliance management system, information system, policy framework, systems or processes for compliance;

iii. investment advisory services;

iv. investment banking services;

v. rendering of outsourced compliance management, record keeping & maintenance services;

vi. management services; and

vii. any other kind of services as may be specified from time to time.

PEOPLE COVERED UNDER DEFINITION OF WORD "RELATIVE" -

Following persons are considered as "relatives"

- members of a Hindu Undivided Family,

- husband and wife

- father, including step-father;

- mother, including step-mother;

- son, including step-son;

- son's wife;

- daughter;

- daughter's husband;

- brother, including step-brother;

- sister, including the step-sister.

The above scope or definition is based on section 2(77) of the Companies Act, 2013 read with rule 4 of the Companies (Specification of definitions details) Rules, 2014.

CAN PARTNERSHIP FIRM OF COMPANY SECRETARIES BE APPOINTED AS SECRETARIAL AUDITORS -

The disqualification list excludes body corporates other than LLPs from being appointed as Secretarial Auditors. Since a partnership firm is not construed to be a body corporate, the same is not disqualified.

NEXUS OF DISQUALIFICATIONS AND THE PROHIBITED SERVICES -

If the disqualifications exist, a company secretary will not be eligible to be appointed as secretarial auditor of Listed Entity. If the disqualifications arise later on, the secretarial auditor will become disentitled to continue his office as a secretarial auditor. There exists a nexus between the disqualifications and the disentitlements. If an auditor provides any of debarred services either to the Listed Entity, or to its holding or subsidiary entity, or its associate or subsidiary of such holding entity, the auditor becomes disqualified as well.

ELIGIBILITY OF PAST EMPLOYEE TO BE APPOINTED AS SECRETARIAL AUDITOR -

As per amended LODR employee is not disqualified. However, as per ICSI Auditing Standards if an auditor was in employment of the auditee, its holding or subsidiary company and 2 years have not lapsed from the date of cessation of employment, the same shall be considered as substantial conflict of interest and auditor cannot have any substantial conflict of interest with the auditee.

CAN SECRETARIAL AUDITOR GET RETAINERSHIP FEES FROM HOLDING ENTITY -

A consulting engagement is not an employment contract because in employment, there is a direct control and supervision of the employer over the employee. So Secretarial auditor get retainership fees from holding entity.

WHETHER SECRETARIAL AUDITOR is DISQUALIFIED, IF SPOUSE IS AN EMPLOYEE IN THE LISTED ENTITY -

If the spouse of the secretarial auditor is a director or Key Managerial Person of Listed Entity, then secretarial auditor will be disqualified.

ADVISORY SERVICES FALL UNDER HEADING PROHIBITED SERVICES OR NOT -

The prohibited list does not contain any reference to advisory services as advisory does not step into management functions.

CONCLUSION

With amendment to Regulation 24A of the LODR there are visible challenges for listed entities to identify and appoint eligible secretarial auditor to conduct mandatory secretarial audits on one hand and challenges for professional Company Secretary on other hand to fulfill need for compliance with the new requirements and potential complexities in identifying and classifying related parties. We are optimistic that SEBI will soon issue a clarification letter or discussion paper regarding revised Regulation 24A of the LODR.

[The views expressed are strictly personal.]

 

TIOL CORP SEARCH

TIOL GROUP WEBSITES

taxindiaonline
taxindiainternational
tioltube
TKF
TIOLawards
A TIOL Website. Copyright © 2025 TIOLcorplaws.com All rights reserved.