Roadshow on First-ever Offshore Areas Mineral Blocks Auction held in Gujarat (See 'Corp Brief') House Panel discusses on Green Initiatives of Coal Sector (See 'Corp Brief') TRAI releases recommendations on assignment of addl spectrum to Railways (See 'Corp Brief') ADB's USD 350 mn policy-based loan aim to expand India's manufacturing sector (See 'Corp Brief') DRDO, IIT Delhi & Industry sign 10 tripartite agreements (See 'Corp Brief') India partners with France to establish Yuga Yugeen Bharat National Museum (See 'Corp Brief') SARFAESI - Obtaining in-principle approval from company's shareholders, as required u/s 62(1)(c) of Companies Act, 2013, is mandatory before allotting shares to any person: SC (See 'Legal Desk') 11th Round of Commercial Coal Mine Auctions: Pre-Bid Meeting Conducted (See 'Corp Brief') IBC - Karnataka HC refrains operational creditors from proceeding with CoC against corporate debtors, finding that NCLT has resumed hearings which was pending vide interim order: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Mandaviya Chairs 195th Meeting of ESIC (See 'Corp Brief') IPR - Once it is concluded that claims are patent ineligible, it is not necessary to deal with other grounds of decision, such as lack of inventive step: HC (See 'Legal Desk') PLI scheme for automobile given budgetary outlay of 25,938 Cr: Govt (See 'Corp Brief') Capital Market - SEBI can't initiate proceeding as soon as Suspicious Transaction Report is issued from financial intelligence unit without getting it analysed: SEBI (See 'Legal Desk') Govt reviews progress to transform India's regulatory ecosystem for medical products (See 'Corp Brief') PMLA - Apex Court grants bail to former West Bengal Education Minister and MLA Partha Chatterjee in money laundering case arising out of recruitment scam: SC (See 'Legal Desk') Council for Leather Exports presents National Export Excellence Awards (See 'Corp Brief') A&C - There cannot be 'optional' arbitration, where parties are required to mutually agree to invoke arbitration clause: SC (See 'Legal Desk') EPFO urges employers to upload wage details till 31st Jan, 2025 (See 'Corp Brief') A&C - Dispute related to wages and termination of employee are non-arbitrable and can be exclusively dealt with by statutory authorities established under Payment of Wages Act and Industrial Disputes Act: SC (See 'Legal Desk') Ministry of Mines webinar on India's First-ever Offshore Areas Mineral Blocks Auction (See 'Corp Brief') SARFAESI - Mere procedural irregularity or deviation from rules are no grounds to set aside confirmed sale, unless such errors are fundamental in nature: SC (See 'Legal Desk') Grant of Classical Language Status to 5 languages shows our commitment: Minister (See 'Corp Brief') SARFAESI - Right to maintenance is equivalent to fundamental right and shall have overriding effect over statutory rights of creditors: SC (See 'Legal Desk') DPIIT inks MoU with Tally Solutions to mentor manufacturing startups (See 'Corp Brief') A&C - Sec 14 of Limitation Act is applicable to Arbitration and Conciliation Act: SC (See 'Legal Desk') India's Multiple Transitions: Financing a big Investment Push (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - No finding, sentence, or order by Special Judge shall be reversed by Court of appeal on ground of absence, error, omission or irregularity in sanction under Prevention of Corruption Act: SC (See 'Legal Desk') CCI okays acquisition of stake of Speed JVco S.a r.l. (Target) by Ramon Investments (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - Absence of specific prayer seeking transfer of possession has no bearing on character of suit, which is one covered by Sec 16(d) of CPC, when transfer of possession of suit property is implicit in contract: SC (See 'Legal Desk') DPIIT conducts over 1,300 programs to foster deeper understanding of IPRs (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - Liability for payment of compensation under NI Act, pending appeal, can only be fastened upon drawer of cheque, and not on company's official who acted as authorized signatory: SC (See 'Legal Desk') IBC amended six times to strengthen process of Insolvency Resolution: Govt (See 'Corp Brief') Misc - Highest bidder in Notice Inviting Tender cannot have vested right to have auction concluded in his favor: SC (See 'Legal Desk')

Group insolvency in Indian insolvency regime

Published: Jun 16, 2023

By Yogendra Aldak, Partner, Pranav Mundra, Senior Associate and Bhavya Shukla, Associate, Lakshmikumaran and Sridharan, Attorneys

 THE law on corporate insolvency resolution process ('CIRP') in India, is majorly focused on the resolution of single entity rather than a group of entities. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code ('Code') provides for initiation of CIRP by creditors when the debt of an entity reaches the threshold. Even if the entities are interconnected, there is no provision in the Code to consolidate the CIRP of all of them. Where group entities are significantly interlinked, it could be value destructive to not recognize such interlinkage. Where the business of different entities is dependent on each other, or various entities have common assets, or where there are common liabilities and related party transactions among entities, carrying of CIRP for each distinct entity in isolation may raise distinct problems, which may not exist otherwise.

To bridge this gap, the company tribunals have attempted to resolve debts of entities that are inextricably linked or are part of a group and where it is necessary for a few or all of them to go through CIRP. In the case of State Bank of India v. Videocon Industries Limited 1, CIRP was initiated by the Bank against 15 companies of Videocon group across various National Company Law Tribunal ('NCLT'). The NCLT Mumbai Bench ordered for consolidation of 13 CIRPs, thereby introducing the concept of group insolvency in India. While considering the law on group insolvency as developed in UK and US, the Mumbai Bench prescribed certain yardstick to ascertain consolidation - Common control, Common directors, Common assets, Common liabilities, Inter-dependence, Inter lacing of finance, Pooling of resources, Co-existence for survival, intricate link of subsidiaries, inter-twined of accounts, inter-looping of debts, singleness of economics of units, cross shareholding, Inter dependence due to intertwined consolidated accounts, Common pooling of resources, etc. The bench clarified that the list was not exhaustive but only prima-facie governing factors to activate the process of 'consolidation'.

The yardstick prescribed in the Videocon Case was followed in Axis Bank Ltd. & Ors. v. Lavasa Corp. Ltd 2 wherein, the financial creditors of the holding company filed for consolidation of its CIRP along with two of its subsidiaries to settle the debts of the entire Lavasa group. The CIRP of Lavasa group was ordered to be consolidated. Even in Radico Khaitan Ltd. v. BT & FC Pvt. Ltd.3, the operational creditor-Radico Khaitan moved the appellate tribunal challenging the order of the NCLT rejecting the request for consolidation. Applying the principles developed in Videocon Case , the appellate tribunal directed for consolidation of two entities.

The need for a holistic framework for group insolvency was recognized by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India ('IBBI') which constituted a Working Group to consider the elements coordination and consolidation in a corporate group. The Working Group addressed key aspects of identification of a group, extent of grouping and mechanism involved. It recommended implementation of group insolvency in two phases – first phase to apply only to domestic companies and second phase to introduce the group insolvency mechanism in cross-border entities. The first phase provided for adoption of rules to coordinate different CIRPs of group entities without disturbing the division of assets and substantive claims of creditors of each of the group entities. The mechanism aimed at lowering costs and reducing time associated with different CIRPs. It consists of elements such as joint application, information sharing between insolvency resolution professionals /NCLTs /Committee of Creditors, consolidation of CIRPs before a single NCLT, creation of group creditor's committees etc. Depending on the implementation of the first phase, the second phase was suggested to be introduced. The second phase provided for mechanism of group insolvency in cross-border CIRPs with substantial consolidation, that is, consolidating the assets and liabilities of group companies so that they are considered to be a single economic unit.

The report of the Working Group has also been considered by the Cross-Border Insolvency Rules/Regulations Committee ('CBIRC') which was constituted by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs ('MCA') to provide recommendations on group insolvency based on a review of recommendations of UNCITRAL Model Law on Enterprise Group Insolvency ('MLEGI') and the Code. The CBIRC in its report inter-alia recommended that MLEGI may not be adopted in India till the time the law on single entity cross-border insolvency is enacted. However, it emphasized on the need for the Code to provide for the manner of undertaking CIRP of group entities that is distinct from the current single-entity approach.

The NCLTs in India have recently been facing special issues arising out of interconnection of CIRP of an entity with its other group companies. Such issues have caught the attention of

IBBI and MCA as well, who have constituted committees seeking recommendations for implementation of group insolvency framework in India. With the recommendations being affirmative, the time is ripe for the Parliament to consider the recommendations and put in place a statutory framework for group insolvency in India. This would not only ensure a timely and effective resolution of insolvency among group entities, but also maximize the value of their assets and balance the interest of all stakeholders of each of the group entities.

(The views expressed are strictly personal.)

12019 SCC OnLine NCLT 745.

2Order dated February 26, 2020 in MA 3664/2019 in C.P.(IB)-1765, 1757 & 574/MB/2018

3Order dated March 26, 2021 in CA(AT) (INS) No. 919/2020 .

TIOL CORP SEARCH

TIOL GROUP WEBSITES