Giriraj Singh visits Welspun World's State-of-the-Art Manufacturing Units in Kutch (See 'Corp Brief') PMLA - Status of secured creditor & initiation of prior recovery proceedings under SARFAESI Act do not exempt a property from attachment under PMLA, when property constitutes proceeds of crime: SAFEMA Tribunal (See 'Legal Desk') Indian Business leaders and Start ups to participate in the India-Egypt Business Forum (See 'Corp Brief') NRIDA selected for Medal for Innovation in Road Technology (See 'Corp Brief') PMLA - Objectives of special anti-money laundering law supersede private commercial security interests - properties linked to criminal activities liable to provisional & final attachment: SAFEMA Tribunal (See 'Legal Desk') Shilp Samagam Mela 2026 at Dilli Haat records Cumulative Sales of Over Rs 88.36 Lakh (See 'Corp Brief') National Tribal Literary Festival concludes with Emphasis on Preserving Oral Traditions (See 'Corp Brief') SEBI - Freezing the Appellants' demat & bank accounts pending deposit of alleged unlawful gains of Rs. 28.12 crore, is valid: SAT (See 'Legal Desk') MoS calls for strengthening India-Italy collaborative research for innovation (See 'Corp Brief') Ministry of Culture invites Partners to Build India's Creative Economy Together (See 'Corp Brief') DoT organises First All India Conference on Official Language 2026 in New Delhi (See 'Corp Brief') Centre strengthens healthcare network through 3 Urban Primary Health Centres (See 'Corp Brief') TDB-DST signs agreement with Astrome to develop sovereign space-based AI-ELINT constellation (See 'Corp Brief') 2nd Edition of the National Tribal Literary Festival 2026 begins in New Delhi (See 'Corp Brief') CCRAS-CARI and University of Delhi sign MoU to document medicinal plant diversity (See 'Corp Brief') RTI - Per Sections 2 & 3 of the Act, CPIO is not obligated to compile, analyze, correlate, or generate fresh datasets from disparate records in specific format desired by applicant: IBBI (See 'Legal Desk') Naturopathy Day 2026: Scientific Research strengthens India's Nature-Based Healthcare Ecosystem (See 'Corp Brief') India and Italy to deepen scientific cooperation through bilateral engagements (See 'Corp Brief') Yadav holds interaction with LeadIT Industry Members and Project Partners (See 'Corp Brief') SEBI - Stay on 5-year debarrment unwarranted where Appellant fails to make out prima facie case - unusual trading pattern noted along with admitted receipt of certain funds from connected entities: SAT (See 'Legal Desk') India strengthens Regional Health Partnerships as First BIMSTEC summit (See 'Corp Brief') CBN dismantles clan lab of mephedrone in Uttar Pradesh (See 'Corp Brief') IPR - Dominant element of composite mark is entitled to standalone protection and party cannot resile from concession made on court record without seeking formal recall of order: HC (See 'Legal Desk') NHAI debars Bijwasan User Fee Collection Agency for One Month (See 'Corp Brief') BEE organises Webinar during BRICS Sustainable Lifestyle Week 2026 (See 'Corp Brief') RTI - Once information held by the public authority is duly disclosed or pointed out, the public authority is under no legal obligation to create, compile, or separately furnish new information: IBBI (See 'Legal Desk') Bharat Mobility Expo to be second largest such expo in the world: Goyal (See 'Corp Brief') MY Bharat organises Nationwide Deepotsav and Neighbourhood Youth Parliaments (See 'Corp Brief') India's Deep-Sea Exploration Is Advancing with MATSYA-6000 and Indo-French Collaboration: MoS (See 'Corp Brief') Round 2 for Surface Coal, Lignite Gasification Projects concludes with 2 Applications from NTPC (See 'Corp Brief') DRI recovers two elephant tusks weighing 3.7 kg (See 'Corp Brief') Govt holds Round Table with CPSEs on Enhancing Procurement from SC/ST MSEs (See 'Corp Brief') SARFAESI - Authority must verify statutory declarations & supporting material & on being satisfied that prescribed requirements are fulfilled, must pass appropriate orders for taking possession of secured asset - cannot adjudicate disputed questions falling beyond limited scope of Section 14: HC (See 'Legal Desk') Special Campaign: Waste Disposal generates revenue of Rs 15.74 Crores (See 'Corp Brief') IBC - Provisions of IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016 contravened where RP unilaterally withdraws higher monthly fee without prior approval of CoC: IBBI (See 'Legal Desk') Delhi Railway Area handles 5 Lakh Passengers Daily - Footfall rises to 8 Lakh during festivals (See 'Corp Brief') IBC- SC exercises power under Article 142 - Borrower firm to pay further sum of 125 crores rupees as full & final settlement of all claims concerning assigned debt: SC LB (See 'Legal Desk') Legislative Department initiates Interaction Series on Personal Effectiveness in Leadership (See 'Corp Brief') National Exercise strengthens India's Preparedness for Foot-and-Mouth Disease (See 'Corp Brief') IBC - Once existence of financial debt & a default is clearly established through unimpeachable evidence & records from information utility, admission of application u/s 7 is mandatory: NCLAT (See 'Legal Desk') An unsuccessful 'success fee' litigation (See CORP EINSICHT)

Pre-listing Bonuses or Splits: An 'Albatross around the neck' of non-resident investors

Published: Aug 13, 2021

By Puneet Jain, Joint Partner & Devashish Jain, Associate in Lakshmikumaran and Sridharan

THE recent IPO announcements by startups in India will bring cheers to existing investors in these companies. However, the possible tax implications arising out of certain internal rearrangements in the shareholding in the run upto the IPO could be seen as an 'albatross around the neck' of investors, especially for those located in Mauritius and Singapore.

Presently, gains derived by Mauritius and Singapore residents from the sale of shares of an Indian company, acquired prior to April 1, 2017, are grandfathered. Accordingly, such gains are not subject to tax in India. However, this position can quickly undergo a change when companies eyeing for IPO issue additional shares to their existing shareholders to bring down their per-share price to make IPO attractive for retail investors.

Broadly speaking, a company can reduce its per-share price either by issuing 'bonus shares' or by announcing a 'stock-split'. The article aims to analyze the income-tax implications associated with these two options from the standpoint of investors resident in Mauritius or Singapore.

A. Bonus Shares

Bonus shares are additional shares given to the existing shareholders of a company on a free-of-charge basis. Investors in companies issuing bonus shares will have the following queries:

1. Whether bonus shares would qualify as a new capital asset?

2. What will be the date of acquisition of such bonus shares?

3. Whether grandfathering benefit under Mauritius or Singapore tax treaties will be available on such bonus shares?

Since the aforesaid queries are interlinked, it is important to conclude on the first two queries, as their conclusions will be a determinative factor in answering the last query.

From a domestic law standpoint, it is now a settled proposition of law that bonus shares shall qualify as a new capital asset. This is primarily due to the fact that they represent "additional share in the increased capital" and "confer title to a larger proportion of the surplus assets at general distribution" 1 . Accordingly, the date of acquisition of these bonus shares shall be seen from the date of their allotment itself 2 .

That being said, it's possible to argue that what stands received by shareholders is merely a split of shares out of his holding 3. Thus, no new property is received in the captioned scenario. However, it is a highly contentious issue, especially in light of the existing jurisprudence.

Resultantly, the issuance of bonus shares may have huge capital gains implications in the hands of non-resident investors resident in Mauritius and Singapore. This is because the bonus shares will be considered to be acquired post-April 1, 2017 upon which no grandfathering benefit would be available under tax treaties.

B. Stock- Split

Stock-split is a corporate action to increase the number of outstanding shares by replacing the existing shares with those having lower denomination and thereby lowering the per-share value in the hands of the shareholders. As an alternative to issuing bonus shares, companies eyeing an IPO can explore 'stock-split' route to lower their per-share price. However, from an investor's standpoint, questions may arise with regard to stock-split similar to those in the case of bonuses.

From a domestic law standpoint, there is very little guidance in the form of judicial precedents on tax implications on share split. However, from the overall scheme of the act 4, it is possible to argue that a mere division of already existing shares into shares of the lower denomination cannot be said to result in emerge of a new capital asset 5. This is because the division/split does not affect the interest of the shareholders in the company. Accordingly, the date of acquisition of the shares received upon stock-split shall be reckoned as the date of issuance of original shares.

That being said, considering the quantum of tax involved, the taxman is likely to contest the aforesaid interpretation. In this regard, they will draw inference from bonus shares to argue that shares issued after stock-split are also new capital assets and accordingly, no grandfathering benefit would be available on such shares. In such an eventuality, the matter may have to be litigated before courts.

Concluding Remarks

As can be seen, both 'bonus shares' and 'stock-split' have their fair share of challenges from an Income-tax perspective. Thus, it boils down to choosing the option with lower risk and higher chances of success in a possible litigation, after considering all the pros and cons. The intent of legislation seems to be ironclad when it comes to bonus shares. Thus, companies eyeing an IPO can consider 'Stock-split' instead of 'bonus shares' to reduce per-share price and help non-resident investors from Mauritius and Singapore to safeguard their grandfathering benefit under treaties.

(Views expressed are strictly personal.)

1CIT v. Chunilal Khushaldas MANU/GJ/0005/1972.

2 Section 2(42A)(f) of the Income-tax Act 1961; Circular No. 717 dated 14-8-1995; and Manecklal Premchand v. CIT MANU/MH/0156/1989.

3 Sudhir Menon v. ACIT MANU/IU/0290/2014.

4Section 55(2)(b)(v) of the Income-tax Act 1961.

5Harish Mahindra / Keshub Mahindra v. CIT [1981] 7 Taxman 89 (Bom.).

TIOL CORP SEARCH

TIOL GROUP WEBSITES