2020-TIOLCORP-06-SC-MISC-LB Dharmaratnakara Rai Vs Bhaskar Raju And Brothers
Whether if lease deed containing arbitration clause is insufficiently stamped then it can not be admitted as evidence and arbitration clause can not be invoked - YES : SC Larger Bench
Whether if deficit duty and penalty is paid in manner set out in Stamp Act, lease deed can be acted upon and admitted in evidence - YES : SC Larger Bench
- Appeal allowed: SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2020-TIOLCORP-05-SC-MISC
Chandigarh Construction Co Pvt Ltd Vs State of Punjab
Whether if the arbitral award is cryptic, the Trial court cannot just modify the award without remanding the matter to the arbitrator to make a fresh consideration - YES: SC
- Appeal partly allowed: SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2020-TIOLCORP-04-SC-MISC-LB
Vijay Karia Vs Prysmian Cavi E Sistemi SRL
Whether where the arbitral award passed under international commercial arbitration is sound in public policy & in conformity with the principles of natural justice, the Apex Court can only address the appeal from refusal to recognise the international commercial arbitration - YES: SC Larger Bench
Whether where the International Arbitral Tribunal has addressed the basic issues of claim & counter - claims & rejects the counter - claim, no challenge before the Apex Court lies before Article 136 of the Constitution against the recognition of foreign arbitral award - YES: SC Larger Bench
- Appeal dismissed: SUPREME COURT OF INDIA (LB) |