Chaucer Capital Ltd Vs Maharashtra Maritime Board

Whether mere existence of breakwater and loosely using the words 'jetty' and 'port', make the facility provided to JSW as multipurpose facility like a commercial port - NO: HC

Whether since due to security concern raised by the Department of Atomic Energy, the project of the petitioner can not be considered, therefore, allegation that MMB and Ministry favouring JSW instead of petitioner is not justified - YES: HC

Whether in absence of issuance of LOI and since no contract being awarded or promised to any of the four contenders, including the petitioner, there is no question of discrimination against the petitioner by favouring JSW - YES: HC

- Writ petition dismissed: BOMBAY HIGH COURT