2017-TIOLCORP-01-HC-DEL-CL
Somi Conveyor Beltings Ltd Vs UoI
Whether DG investigation ordered by CCI would amount to an adjudicatory function calling for application of the principle of 'audi altrem partem' i.e. giving an opportunity to the other party - NO: HC
Whether right available to a party to the proceedings to inspect the records or obtain copies thereof is not absolute and is subject to the permission granted by CCI in that behalf - YES: HC
Whether CCI can refuse to grant permission for inspection of records or furnishing copies thereof if it is of the view that the documents/ information require confidential treatment - YES: HC
Whether confidentiality being maintained u/s 57 by CCI by rejecting the request for inspection or obtaining copies by means of delegated Legislation is arbitral, unreasonable or unconstitutional - NO : HC
Whether the constitutional validity of such Delegated Legislation can be challenged if it is manifestly arbitrary or is so unreasonable that Parliament never intended to confer such power on the Regulator - YES: HC
- Petition Dismissed: DELHI HIGH COURT