2017-TIOLCORP-36-HC-DEL-IPR

F Hoffmann-la-roche Ltd Vs Natco Pharma Ltd

Whether the party who initiated the revocation proceedings of patent is responsible to prove why the patent is not an invention within the meaning of the Patents Act - YES : HC

Whether objections as to why patent be revoked, must be clearly mentioned - YES : HC

Whether a report of the expert can be considered as a relevant fact in a case pertaining to patent revocation - YES : HC

Whether in a case relating to patents, a report by expert can compared with report of a handwriting expert - NO : HC

- Application Dismissed: DELHI HIGH COURT

2017-TIOLCORP-17-HC-MUM-MISC

Manoj Javeri Stock Broking Pvt Ltd Vs Gopika S Mehta

Whether there exists a relationship of trust between Share broker and it's constituent - YES: HC

Whether it amounts to breach of trust when certain shares handed over to the stock broker for safe keeping have been lost - YES : HC

Whether such stock broker is liable to pay damages for failing to return the shares to the rightful owner - YES: HC

Whether such dishonest conduct of the stock broker shall be subject to arbitration mechanism under the bye-laws of the stock exchange - YES: HC

- Petition Dismissed: BOMBAY HIGH COURT